Church Shooting: Rethinking Safety Beyond Lockdowns

The call came on a Wednesday afternoon. It wasn’t an active shooter, but a bomb threat at a local school that shared a campus with the church. In those frantic moments, questions raced through the mind: Do we evacuate the preschool? Do we cancel evening services? For Sam Rainer, a pastor who lived through this scenario, the threat didn’t materialize—but the panic was real.

For most of us, the concept of a church shooting feels like a dystopian headline—something that happens to “other” congregations in “other” towns. But in 2026, the data tells a different story. According to the Family Research Council, from January 2018 through December 2024, there were 1,384 documented acts of hostility against American churches. While total incidents dipped slightly in 2024 compared to the previous year, the numbers remain “significantly higher” than the totals recorded between 2018 and 2022.

This isn’t just about statistics; it is about the erosion of the one place many of us viewed as a sanctuary. Whether you are a church trustee, a volunteer nursery worker, or simply a concerned parishioner, understanding the landscape of church safety is no longer optional—it is a critical part of stewardship.

The Changing Face of the Threat

When we hear “church shooting,” our minds often jump to ideological hatred or organized hate groups. However, the reality is far more complex—and in some ways, more tragic. While anti-LGBT and political ideologies still play a role, recent data shows a sharp decline in incidents motivated by specific issues like pro-abortion sentiments, dropping from 59 in 2022 to just 2 in 2024.

So, what is driving the violence?

• Mental Health Crises: A significant number of incidents involve individuals experiencing psychotic breaks or untreated mental illness. In one high-profile 2024 shooting at Lakewood Church in Houston, the shooter had a documented history of mental health struggles.

• Personal Grievance: Many perpetrators harbor a personal grievance—a lost job, a broken relationship—and they displace that rage onto a soft target.

• “Vandalism Gone Wrong”: Sometimes, what starts as petty vandalism or theft (like stealing copper wiring) escalates when the perpetrator is confronted.

Understanding this mix of motives is crucial. It means that a security plan cannot just focus on the “outsider with a manifesto”; it must also account for the desperate individual wandering in off the street.

Practical Safety: It Starts with the Greeting Team

For a small business owner or a freelancer reading this, you understand risk assessment. You lock your office, you back up your data. For a church, the principle is the same, but the execution requires grace.

You don’t need to turn your fellowship hall into a bunker. You need to build a culture of awareness. Here is how modern churches are adapting their physical spaces and training:

1. The “Run, Hide, Fight” Framework

Law enforcement agencies, including the FBI, universally recommend this protocol for active shooter situations. It is simple enough to remember even when adrenaline is spiking:

• Run: If there is an escape path, try to evacuate. Leave belongings behind. Help others escape if possible, but don’t let their indecision slow you down.

• Hide: If evacuation isn’t possible, find a place out of the shooter’s view. Lock doors and barricade them with furniture. Silence your phone and remain absolutely quiet.

• Fight: As a last resort, and only when your life is in imminent danger, attempt to disrupt or incapacitate the shooter. This is not about heroism; it is about survival.

2. The “Stay or Go” Decision Tree

Churches are complex environments. You might have 200 people in the sanctuary and 20 toddlers in the nursery. A one-size-fits-all plan fails. Many churches now use a simple “Stay or Go” framework for classroom volunteers:

• Evacuate (Go): If the threat is outside the building or in a different area, and a safe route is clear.

• Shelter in Place (Stay): If the threat is inside the building. This involves locking doors, covering windows, and hiding out of sight.

3. Leveraging Free Resources

You don’t have to hire a high-priced security consultant. In fact, the government wants to help.

• Home Office Training (UK): In England and Wales, the Home Office has launched Faith Security Training (FST) , a free scheme to help faith communities mitigate threats.

• DOJ Partnerships (USA): The U.S. Department of Justice regularly hosts forums like “Protecting Places of Worship,” bringing together the FBI, local law enforcement, and faith leaders to discuss threat assessments and grant opportunities.

• Local Sheriff Programs: Local law enforcement is stepping up. For example, the DeKalb County Sheriff’s Office in Alabama now offers scenario-based training for church security teams to practice decision-making under stress.

*Related: You might also be interested in “How to Apply for FEMA Security Grants for Nonprofits.” *

Beyond the Bullet: Trauma and Community Aftermath

What happens after the police tape comes down? The media leaves, but the congregation remains. The psychological impact of a church shooting or even a credible threat can linger for years.

Consider the Natawa School model in Vanuatu, which, while focused on general violence prevention, highlights a universal truth: safety is a community effort. After an incident, churches must pivot from physical security to emotional first aid.

• Communicating with Children: The National Child Traumatic Stress Network suggests using simple, direct language with kids—reassuring them that they are safe without delving into graphic details.

• The Role of Leadership: In the aftermath of a tragedy at a Minnesota church, Archbishop Bernard Hebda reminded mourners that even in a “House of God,” tragedy can occur, pointing them toward hope rather than despair -3. Leaders must validate the fear while refusing to let it define the faith community.

Building a Culture of Preparedness (Without Paranoia)

We must walk a fine line. Jesus called us to be “wise as serpents and innocent as doves.” In 2026, this might look like a security team that prays together before they patrol. It might look like a greeter who is trained to spot a suspicious package because they actually look people in the eye, not just because they are checking a box.

St. Augustine famously said, “Pray as though everything depended on God. Work as though everything depended on you.”. We prepare, not because we live in fear, but because we live in hope—and we want to protect the vulnerable among us.

FAQs

Q:1 What should I do immediately if I hear gunshots inside my church?

Your first action should be to run in the opposite direction of the sound if a safe path is available. If not, hide in a room that can be locked or barricaded, silence your phone, and remain still.

Q:2 Are churches actually being attacked more often, or does it just seem that way?

Attacks are statistically higher. From 2018 to 2024, the Family Research Council documented 1,384 hostile incidents. While 2024 saw a slight decrease from 2023’s peak, the numbers are still significantly elevated compared to 2018.

Q:3 What is the “Run, Hide, Fight” protocol?

It is a survival strategy endorsed by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. Run to escape danger, Hide if escape is impossible, and as a last resort, Fight to disrupt or incapacitate the attacker.

Q:4 My church has no budget for security. Where can we get free help?

Contact your local FBI field office or U.S. Attorney’s Office; they often host free “Places of Worship” safety forums. In the UK, the Home Office offers free Faith Security Training (FST).

Q:5 How do we talk to kids about an active shooter situation without scaring them?

Use age-appropriate language. For young children, focus on safety drills as a way to stay “safe and sound” like a game of hide-and-seek. Reassure them that adults are working hard to protect them.

Q:6 Should we arm our congregation?

This is a deeply personal decision that varies by denomination and local laws. However, experts suggest that if firearms are present, they must be handled by trained, vetted security teams—not random congregants—to avoid accidental discharges or friendly fire incidents.

Q:7 What motivates most church shooters?

Motives vary widely, but many are linked to personal grievances, domestic violence spilling over, or mental health crises rather than purely ideological hatred.

Q:8. What is a “soft target”?

A “soft target” is a location with limited security measures, making it vulnerable to attack. Churches are often considered soft targets due to their open-door policies and large gatherings.

Q:9 How can our security team practice effectively?

Scenario-based training is best. Work with local law enforcement to run drills. The DeKalb County Sheriff’s Office model uses simulated stress to help teams learn to make decisions under pressure.

Q:10 Are there grants available to improve church security?

Yes. In the U.S., the Department of Homeland Security and FEMA offer grants for nonprofit security. State programs also exist. Contact your local CISA (Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency) representative for guidance.

Q:11 What should be in a church emergency kit?

At a minimum: a first aid kit (including trauma bandages and tourniquets), flashlights, batteries, a battery-powered radio, bottled water, and a list of emergency contacts and medical information for staff.

Q:12 How do we handle a bomb threat differently from an active shooter?

In a bomb threat, the priority is usually evacuation to a safe distance (at least 300 feet). In an active shooter situation, the immediate priority might be hiding in place to avoid encountering the shooter.

Q:13 What if the perpetrator is someone we know, like a disgruntled former member?

This is a common scenario. Your safety team should have a protocol for “disruptive individuals,” including knowing when to deny entry and having a crisis line contact ready to de-escalate the situation before it turns violent.

Conclusion

We gather in churches to find peace, but we cannot ignore the realities of a broken world. Addressing the threat of a church shooting isn’t about surrendering to fear; it is about loving our neighbors enough to keep them safe. Whether it is taking a free security course offered by the government or simply knowing the evacuation route from your pew, preparation is an act of care.

As you leave for church this week, take a moment to look at the exits. Say hello to a security team member. Pray for peace, but be ready to act. That is the balance we are called to live in 2026.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION, VISIT: THESOLOMAG